Can Goldfish and Tropical Fish Live Together
Mixing goldfish and tropical fish in the same aquarium is a common consideration among fishkeepers looking to diversify their tanks. While it might seem like a good idea to combine these vibrant and fascinating species, there are important factors to consider before deciding whether goldfish and tropical fish can coexist. This article will explore the compatibility of goldfish with tropical fish by examining differences in their requirements and behaviors, along with some possible tankmate options.
Key Differences Between Goldfish and Tropical Fish
1. Water Temperature
Goldfish are adapted to cold water for their survival, hence requiring temperatures between 65°F and 75°F (18°C–24°C). Tropical fish require warmer water, usually between 75°F and 82°F (24°C–28°C), which makes it challenging to maintain the water temperature stable for both species and can be harmful for one group.
2. Dietary Needs
Goldfish are opportunistic omnivores with a high appetite and tend to eat everything that is available, including tropical fish food. Although there is some overlap in diet, the tropical fish may not receive adequate nutrition if the goldfish consume their food before they can.
3. Tank Size and Filtration
Goldfish produce more waste than most tropical fish, so they need robust filtration systems to maintain water quality. Such increased bio-load can cause stress or health problems for the tropical fish that prefer pristine water conditions. Furthermore, goldfish grow much larger than most tropical fish, often requiring more swimming space.
4. Behavioral Differences
Generally peaceful, goldfish can become problem tankmates. They tend to root around in the substrate and, doing so, may uproot plants and dislodge decorations, stressing other fish. They are also relatively slow swimmers, which may expose them to fin-nipping by aggressive tropical fish.
Potential Goldfish and Tropical Fish Pairings
If you’re determined to house goldfish and tropical fish together, selecting the right species is crucial. Look for fish that can tolerate cooler water temperatures and are peaceful in nature. Here are a few tropical fish that may cohabitate with goldfish under specific conditions:
1. White Cloud Mountain Minnows
Temperature Range: 60°F–72°F (15°C–22°C)- Behavior: Peaceful and active, making them suitable companions for goldfish.
- Notes: With their small size and capability of thriving in relatively cool water, they are some of the best options.
Temperature Range: 50° -75°F (10° -24°C)- Behaviour: Peace-loving bottom-dwellers which will often get on fine with goldfish
- Notes: They can survive on the same temperature and may clean up uneaten food
:strip_icc()/Puntius_conchonius_Dornenwolf-56a32ff15f9b58b7d0d0dfd6.jpg)
Temperature Range: 64° – 72° F (18°-22° C)- Behavior: Schooling fish but relatively peaceful.
- Notes: It’s active and coloured fish. It brings lively looks into a goldfish aquarium.
Considerations for a Mixed Tank
- Tank Size: The tank should be large enough to hold the bio-load of goldfish and provide swimming space for all species. A minimum tank size of 30 gallons (114 liters) is recommended.
- Filtration: A high-quality filter is necessary to manage waste and maintain water clarity, as goldfish are messy eaters.
- Water Temperature: Aim for a compromise temperature between 70°F and 72°F (21°C–22°C). However, this may not be ideal for all tropical fish species.
- Tank Setup: Provide ample hiding spots and decorations to reduce stress and encourage natural behavior among all tank inhabitants.
- Regular Maintenance: Perform frequent water changes to maintain optimal water quality and reduce ammonia levels caused by goldfish waste.
When Goldfish and Tropical Fish Shouldn’t Be Mixed
In most cases, it is not advisable to mix goldfish with tropical fish. Some tropical fish species, such as betta, guppies, and tetras, cannot tolerate lower temperatures and will be aggressive toward goldfish. Moreover, goldfish may eat small tropical fish by mistake due to their appetite for food.
Stress from incompatible tankmates can lead to various health problems, including compromised immune systems and susceptibility to disease.
Conclusion
While it is possible to keep goldfish and tropical fish together under certain conditions, it’s not always the best idea. The different water temperatures, diets, and requirements for tanks make it difficult to create a harmonious environment for both species. When you choose to mix goldfish and tropical fish, choose those that can tolerate cooler water temperatures and provide a big, well-maintained tank with excellent filtration. For most aquarists, it’s preferable to focus on creating separate tanks tailored to the needs of each group.
FAQs (frequently-asked questions)
No, guppies require warmer water (75°F–82°F) than goldfish, so they won’t be good tank mates.
A minimum of 30 gallons is recommended, but bigger is always better to house both groups.
Yes, goldfish may eat small tropical fish such as neon tetras if they can fit in their mouths.
White Cloud Mountain Minnows, Dojo Loaches, and Rosy Barbs are good choices.
Generally, no. Goldfish prefer cooler water, and the tank temperature should be adjusted to compatible species.
